Thursday, January 21, 2010

Rise of the Terran Empire - Poul Anderson

Rise of the Terran Empire is the third in a series of seven books collecting all of Anderson's writings in the Technic civilization setting. The stories are presented by internal chronology and in this book we have reached the boundary between the two eras Anderson put most of these stories in. The time of the Polesotechnic league, Nicolas van Rijn and David Falkayn and the era of the Terran Empire and Dominic Flandry. The previous two books contained quite a few pieces of short fiction but this third tome includes two full novels with room left over for four shorter works. One of these, Sargasso of Lost Starships, originally published in Planet Stories, appears for the first time in book form so if you are a completist this is a must have.

The collection opens with the 1977 novel Mirkheim. It features both Falkayn and van Rijn in what will be their last adventure. A war between a recently civilized alien species and the Commonwealth over a planet rich in rare metals Falkayn discovered earlier in his career, shows just how unprepared, weak and utterly divided the Commonwealth and the Polesotechnic league have become. Van Rijn decides to gather the crew of spaceship Muddlin' Trough for a mission of intelligence gathering before hostilities break out.

It features some peculiar monologues by van Rijn of the virtues of being an independent trader and the evils of government and regulations. Given the state of the league and van Rijn's unmistakable dissatisfaction with it, I must say I have some trouble grasping his position at times. Anderson creates a very dark, gloomy atmosphere in this book, as if everybody is waiting for the end of an era, which I suppose is what this book heralds. I thought it was an interesting read but the second novel contained in this volume is more interesting.

Before we get to that there are a few shorter pieces first though. Wingless (1973, sometimes referred to as Wingless on Avalon) is the first of a number of stories in this collection featuring the birdlike Ythrians, and a joint human/Ythri colony on Avalon. A descendant young descendant of Falkayn spends a lot of time in the company of a group of rather condescending Ythrian youths. They soon find out that being able to fly isn't a benefit in all situations. This story was a bit too moralizing for my taste. It doesn't help that the next one is a variation on this theme.

Rescue on Avalon (1973) is another story of Ythrian/human interaction on Avalon. A young human finds himself the only one close enough to assist a Ythrian in serious trouble after a big storm. He secretly holds a grudge against the Ythrians but rescues him anyway and learns there is strength in diversity. Same comment as the previous story really.

In the next story, The Starplunderer (1952), we meet the founder of the Terran Empire. The commonwealth has weakened to a point where human controlled space is being overrun by barely civilized alien races. During the second sack of earth John Henry Reeves is taken prisoner by the Gorzuni. On the ship carrying him away from earth he meets Manuel, a man with designs to take over the ship and he can use John's help to achieve this aim. Manuel has quite a megalomaniac streak. It makes him a very interesting character. Given the pivotal moment in Technic history it describes I am surprised it never made it into one of the earlier collections of Technic history material. I quite liked it.

In Sargasso of Lost Starships (1951) we see the empire several generations after Manuel founds it. It's still expanding rapidly. Basil Donovan, former nobleman from a recent addition to the empire is dragged away on a mission to explore a nearby nebula. The Terrans do not know what to expect but he has been there before. It is not a place he particularly wants to return to. This 1950s story is a bit pulpy, which I generally do not like. Anderson creates a very alien and somewhat scary atmosphere in Sargasso of Lost Starships that made me overcome my usual feelings of pulp SF. It's creepy but I liked it a lot.

The novel People of the Wind (1973), which got Anderson Nebula, Hugo and Locus award nominations, closes this volume. In this novel a large Terran fleet sets out to readjust the border with the Ythrian dominated Dominion. The Dominion does not seem to stand a chance against the might of the Terran Empire but especially on Avalon, people have decided to make conquest as expensive as possible. For such a short novel Anderson uses an awful lot of different points of view. On the one hand this gives us a very detailed idea of what is going on. On the other, I didn't quite grow attached to any of them. Anderson includes quite a bit of personal drama in his story. I think it could have had a bigger impact if he had focussed to story on a few less characters. It is nonetheless the best piece in this collection, not at all hard to see why it got all those award nominations.

The two stories I did not like where the shortest of the bunch, so overall I liked this volume quite a lot. Without the focus on van Rijn and Falkayn it is a bit more varied than the previous volume David Falkayn: Star Trader. The transition from the Commonwealth to the Empire is, despite the fact that these stories were written over a period of twenty-five years, a recognizable overarching theme in all if them. When you think about this, it certainly is an achievement to write such an impressive future history completely out of chronological order and end up with something that on most levels makes sense. The fourth volume, Young Flandry, is published this month. Despite me liking this book a lot, I still haven't decided whether I will buy a copy. The cover art is an atrocious for one thing. For another, Flandry is something of a James Bond in space. I am not entirely sure if that kind of story suits me. No regrets on purchasing Rise of the Terran Empire though, I just wish Baen had continued this series in hardcover instead of switching to paperback.

Book Details
Title: Rise of the Terran Empire
Author: Poul Anderson
Publisher: Baen
Pages: 480
Year: 2009
Language: English
Format: Paperback
ISBN: 978-1-4391-3275-3
First published: 2009


  1. I rather agree about the cover, but Anderson developed Dlandry quute a bit beyond the Bondish rogue uin the early stories. The stories are full of shades of grey as well as more top notch planetology. I have been meaning to pick up this collection, getting it rebound when I do!

  2. It is an interesting project by Baen isn't it? I've decided to read the rest as well and hope Anderson manages to develop Flandy beyond the Bond in space.

  3. Just a note that "The Star Plunderer" from this collection actually DID appear in a previous collection entitled The Long Night which was released in 1983. Check out the Wikipedia article on Poul Anderson for more details. I also verified it in my copy of The Long Night.

  4. Oops, you're right. I may have misread Davis' introduction.